If any one of these is true for your door, replacement usually beats repair on total cost of ownership.
The door is over 20 years old
Modern doors are quieter, better insulated and code-compliant on wind load.
Multiple panels are damaged
Once you're replacing more than one section, the math tips toward a new door.
The door was uninsulated
An insulated replacement often pays back in AC savings within 5-8 years in Naples.
Selling within 2 years
Garage door replacement returns 90 to 100 percent of cost in resale value — one of the highest of any home improvement.
